Matter Explorer

Inspect all 80 matters

Choose any of the six model pairings, then search, filter, and open the underlying matter. Each record links to all four answers, every blind judgment, the prompt, the sealed key, and supporting files.

480

blind judgments

Four models, six pairings per matter, and 80 closed-record legal assignments.

Qwen 3.8 vs Claude

Select a bar to filter the currently selected comparison.

0 to 80 scale
80 matters
Q01
The Pharmaceutical Packaging LineCommercial contracts
Series 1Tie
Both answers place LumaBio on the same material path: preserve evidence, issue a specific deduction notice, verify performance under compliant humidity and film conditions, avoid immediate litigation or continued unsecured withholding, and negotiate an engineering remedy plus a supported credit.
Open record
Q02
The Remote Accommodation TerminationEmployment
Series 1Claude win
Answer A identifies a separate, unconditional reinstatement offer as a mitigation measure, while Answer B recommends reinstatement only within a negotiated settlement requiring a release.
Open record
Q03
The Autonomous Forklift AccidentProduct liability
Series 1Tie
Both answers place VectorMotion on the same material path: treat design and post-sale-warning exposure as substantial, reject superseding causation as the primary defense, pursue an early global settlement with SafePath participation, preserve contractual claims, and implement immediate fleet-safety…
Open record
Q04
The SUV, the Backpack, and the PhoneCriminal procedure
Series 1Tie
Both readers would litigate the stop’s prolongation and derivative taint, the backpack search, the warrantless phone review and later warrant, the out-of-scope photographs, and the two-stage interrogation.
Open record
Q05
The Founder’s AcquisitionCorporate transactions
Series 1Tie
Both answers place the board on the same material path: assume entire-fairness review, preserve evidence, establish a genuinely independent litigation process with separate advisers, obtain an independent valuation, preserve claims against Peak, and evaluate settlement only after investigation.
Open record
Q06
The Departing AI Product DirectorTrade secrets
Series 1Tie
Both answers direct LexCore away from the requested noncompete-like restraint, feature-wide injunction, wholesale imaging, and blanket customer ban, and toward prompt preservation, identified-secret protections, targeted forensics and discovery, and enforcement limited to material-contact customers.
Open record
Q07
The Altered Board MinutesProfessional responsibility
Series 1Tie
Both answers end the joint representation, preserve all evidence, correct the government’s false understanding before the deadline, truthfully produce the altered draft and metadata, decline Nora’s immunity request, and transition Samuel, Nora, and the adverse internal investigation to independent counsel.
Open record
Q08
The Cloud Outage LawsuitTechnology litigation
Series 1Tie
Both answers direct BrightForge to seek remand because Leo has a reasonable fraud claim and therefore defeats complete diversity. They also preserve the same fallback path: oppose arbitration for lack of assent, defend jurisdiction over Orbit, contest transfer, prioritize fraud and consumer-protection…
Open record
Q09
The Deleted Messages and Privileged MemorandumDiscovery and privilege
Series 1Tie
Both answers put Northstar on the same material path: concede the preservation gaps, undertake and fund targeted recovery, oppose a case-wide adverse inference and blanket phone imaging, permit limited preservation discovery, and enforce the memorandum’s clawback.
Open record
Q10
The Easement and the Recovery RetreatProperty and housing
Series 1Tie
Both answers place Haven Ridge on the same material path: treat full retreat access at 70 daily trips as unlikely under the express easement, stop unauthorized work, pursue narrowly restored lawful access, and negotiate a recorded expansion with compensation and operational limits while evaluating redesign…
Open record
Q11
The Time-Limited DemandInsurance and settlement
Series 1Tie
Both answers direct Harborline to demand a full defense, independent counsel, and acceptance of the $950,000 demand with explicit notice of entire-judgment liability, while avoiding an unconsented settlement and preserving rights in any contribution agreement.
Open record
Q12
The Copyleft AuditSoftware licensing
Series 1Tie
Both readers end on the same material path: treat device shipments as infringement, reject the cloud demand, determine firmware scope through technical review, release the covered source, pursue a narrow neutral audit and settlement, preserve evidence, and disclose the matter to the acquirer.
Open record
Q13
The Hold You Must WriteDiscovery and preservation
Series 1Tie
Both answers put counsel on the same material path: immediately preserve the messaging-app data and Bell’s endpoint, suspend every identified deletion or overwrite process, preserve contractor and vendor-held materials, collect the relevant systems, and maintain a continuing hold without custodian…
Open record
Q14
The Redline MandateTechnology transactions
Series 1Qwen 3.8 win
Answer A applies a supercap to purported “Data Security Obligations” but never imposes an affirmative safeguards or security-incident notification obligation on Vendor. Answer B supplies both covenants, giving Bellhaven enforceable security and notice rights rather than a cap governing obligations that the…
Open record
Q15
The Preference DemandBankruptcy
Series 1Tie
After unsupported estimates are rejected, both answers direct Pinion to defend the first three payments, treat the February 27 payment as exposed, subtract only documented post-February 27 unsecured new value, preserve the $95,000 administrative claim and double-duty argument, avoid unilateral setoff, and…
Open record
Q16
The Ransomware WeekendCybersecurity
Series 1Qwen 3.8 win
Answer A concludes that participant-data acquisition is already reasonably likely but postpones the formal determination for up to 10 days, improperly shifting the notification clocks.
Open record
Q17
The Review FloodDiscovery review
Series 1Tie
Both answers direct Lumen away from a broad Friday lawsuit and toward preservation, removal and settlement of the Voss disclosure, platform enforcement, pre-suit identification, and narrowly supported claims only after assembling admissible evidence sufficient to survive the special motion.
Open record
Q18
The Rock, the Tank, and the ClockEnvironmental law
Series 1Tie
Both readers keep the crew working, respond within the cure period, preserve the differing-site-condition and waiver arguments, demand payment and proof of owner nonpayment, and timely record a lien limited to supportable amounts.
Open record
Q19
The Second CodicilTrusts and estates
Series 1Tie
After ordinary verification, both readers preserve the evidence, pursue the brokerage-account and exploitation claims without triggering the no-contest clause, seek mediation, and evaluate a timely codicil contest based principally on undue influence.
Open record
Q20
The Hot ARR DeckSecurities and finance
Series 1Tie
Both answers direct Northgate to halt the existing process, preserve evidence, correct ARR and NRR, disclose the non-renewal, remediate the anchor through rescission or amended terms with a release, freeze the secondary, and negotiate any financing only after complete disclosure.
Open record
Q21
The Plea Offer Before DawnCriminal law
Series 2Tie
Both answers place Malik on the same material path: accept the plea if avoiding the 55% risk of 76–100 additional months controls, while recognizing that trial preserves the stated chances of avoiding robbery and the three-year license suspension.
Open record
Q22
The Proffer RoomCriminal law
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Lena not to attend tomorrow, to seek postponement while obtaining written use restrictions, cooperation terms, participant-status information, and a defined subject list, and to decline if adequate protections are refused.
Open record
Q23
Two Forums, One WitnessParallel proceedings
Series 2Tie
Both answers place Bexley on the same material path: preserve records immediately, retain separate counsel for exposed individuals, timely produce nonprivileged corporate records in both forums, withhold the privileged memorandum, reject the proposed declaration, request the prosecutor’s position, and seek…
Open record
Q24
The Motion That Chased the Wrong SearchCriminal procedure
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct counsel to suppress the fentanyl and out-of-scope phone photograph, abandon staleness and knock-and-announce as suppression theories, concede the physical handgun’s lawful plain-view seizure, and preserve the remaining evidence through severability.
Open record
Q25
Sentencing Memorandum for Jana OrtizCriminal sentencing
Series 2Tie
Both answers place the court on the same materially correct path: 12 months and one day of custody, supervised release, and restitution payments calibrated to Jana’s $1,700 monthly disposable income.
Open record
Q26
The Hotline ClockCompliance and investigations
Series 2Tie
Both answers place Solstice on the same materially correct path: immediate preservation of perishable data and personal work devices, suspension of suspect payments and Cole’s authority, an independent committee-directed outside-counsel investigation, protected interviews, rapid payment tracing, and an…
Open record
Q27
The Whistleblower the Manager Wants GoneEmployment
Series 2Tie
Both answers reject immediate for-cause termination and permit separation only on February 15 through faithful implementation of the pre-report restructuring: all four positions genuinely eliminated, no substantially similar replacement, eight weeks’ severance, independent review, neutral communications…
Open record
Q28
The Files in Serena's ApartmentTrade secrets and data
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct counsel to preserve and produce Categories A and E through protected channels, sequester Category C with notice and a privilege protocol, and return or delete Categories B and D only through a documented forensic process.
Open record
Q29
The Relapse Before the Step-Up HearingFamily law
Series 2Tie
Both answers place Tessa on the same material path: reject emergency or immediate-equal-time litigation, candidly acknowledge the relapse, impaired driving, and nondisclosure, negotiate Daniel’s 90-day framework with objective safeguards, and build a sustained record before seeking phased expansion.
Open record
Q30
The Wallets Behind the DivorceFamily law
Series 2Tie
Both readers calculate the known holdings as $280,000 separate and $140,000 marital, identify Mira’s $70,000 baseline share, provisionally classify the second wallet as marital, and calculate a possible total recovery of $154,000 if intentional concealment is proved.
Open record
Q31
The Prenup Memo AuditFamily law
Series 2Tie
Both answers place Nora on the same material path: accept enforcement of the property and business provisions, demand the vested $150,000 payment, and seek only the maintenance necessary to avoid public-assistance eligibility.
Open record
Q32
The Workforce Audit CalendarEmployment compliance
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Arclight to produce the requested forms and roster by April 8 absent a written extension, cure the technical defects by April 26 without backdating, and deliver mismatch notices by April 21 while calculating separate eight-business-day periods from actual employee receipt.
Open record
Q33
The Stop-Time ProvisoImmigration
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct counsel to argue that residence stopped on April 20, 2021, that Idris accrued seven years, that none of the three dispositions is disqualifying or clock-stopping, and that counsel should substantiate good moral character and medical hardship through motions and documentary evidence.
Open record
Q34
The Installers on Form 1099Employment classification
Series 2Tie
Both answers reject a zero reserve, calculate the same $354,922.40 nonwillful reserve, identify element B as likely fatal, and direct immediate preservation and factual investigation before conceding classification.
Open record
Q35
The Account Before the Bank List ArrivesTax compliance
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Priya to make an immediate, truthful voluntary disclosure at a fixed $228,000 cost, reject the unsupported nonwillful certification, and advise against quiet returns or waiting because of higher expected costs, referral exposure, and imminent loss of eligibility.
Open record
Q36
The Subpoena and the Privilege LogDiscovery and privilege
Series 2Qwen 3.8 win
Answer A directs Oriole to produce all factual data generated during Emberline’s counsel-directed litigation-and-enforcement engagement, even though Rule 5 protects material prepared primarily because of anticipated litigation or enforcement.
Open record
Q37
The Engineer's License HearingAdministrative licensing
Series 2Tie
Both readers would reject the current all-charges offer, immediately obtain the complete prior-discipline file, seek an extension and disclosure order or continuance, preserve the fraud denial, and condition settlement versus hearing on whether a qualifying final order exists.
Open record
Q38
The Rule That Changed After Comment ClosedAdministrative law
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Meridian to file immediately, seek an expedited stay before the contract deadline, challenge the threshold and supply-chain requirements for inadequate notice, demand reopening over the undisclosed model, press the significant-comment and good-cause defects, defeat harmlessness, and seek…
Open record
Q39
The Copper Discharge DecreeEnvironmental law
Series 2Claude win
Answer A grants Selwick a civil release for the disclosed pre-Effective-Date violations upon payment of the civil penalty, while Answer B conditions that release on full and timely performance of the entire Decree.
Open record
Q40
The Dry-Cleaner ParcelReal estate and environment
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Brindle to obtain Phase II results before closing, preserve innocent-purchaser protection, reject the $500,000 escrow and final-judgment condition on the present record, and require an escrow of $2,118,000 unless testing supports a different supplied branch.
Open record
Q41
The Tenant's Five-Day FuseCommercial leasing
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Lantern Row to pay the full $160,000 by March 6 under a reservation preserving the March claim, cure insurance promptly, document the excused operating closure, reject February relief, and submit final March sales by April 10 for a $48,000 credit if the below-70% threshold is proven.
Open record
Q42
The Collector's LedgerConsumer finance
Series 2Claude win
The January 18 voicemail was a call made after the cease-call request, so Rule 5 raises post-cease-call damages from $1,500 to the $2,000 cap. Answer B expressly directs counsel to plead and preserve that additional $500 theory; Answer A omits it and recommends a $15,200 counterclaim, leaving the additional…
Open record
Q43
The Furnace and the March RentLandlord and tenant
Series 2Tie
Both readers would authorize and pay for the licensed $1,400 repair today, then timely pay $250 with the invoice, proof of payment, and supporting records. Both would preserve but not deduct the $260 hotel claim, avoid total withholding or immediate termination, and retain evidence for any retaliation…
Open record
Q44
What Supervisors May SayLabor law
Series 2Claude win
Answer B instructs supervisors to say bargaining begins from a “current agreement” or “current contract,” although these employees are not presently represented and no contract exists.
Open record
Q45
The Strike After the Schedule CutLabor law
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Ironvale to treat the differential cut as unlawful, classify the mixed-motive strike as an unfair-practice strike, immediately reinstate nonmisconduct strikers by displacing replacements, address back pay from June 25 subject to mitigation, investigate misconduct individually, restore…
Open record
Q46
The Protest That Keeps the StayGovernment contracts
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Silverline to omit the waived solicitation challenge, treat September 4 as the knowledge date, and ensure Board receipt by September 11 rather than pursue the agency-first sequence.
Open record
Q47
The Tower Contract Termination ProposalGovernment contracts
Series 2Qwen 3.8 win
Answer A preserves the unsupported $420,000 idle-labor claim for later resolution, while Answer B’s operative global-settlement term releases it despite earlier calling it reserved.
Open record
Q48
The Lien Two Days Before ClosingReal estate and liens
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct North Quay to give notice by Thursday, honor the five-business-day cure period, reject the unsupported $300,000 holdback and indemnity, and close only after a current payoff supports payment/release or a 125% insurer-approved escrow yielding exception-free policies and lender funding.
Open record
Q49
The Deposit After the Missed ClosingReal estate contracts
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Adrian to concede default, uphold the sole-remedy liquidated-damages clause, allow retention of the $90,000 deposit, tender the $18,000 shortfall, and reject all additional damages and fees.
Open record
Q50
The Operating Agreement and the Side LetterCorporate governance
Series 2Tie
Both answers place the members on the same material path: the incorporated side letter controls within its scope, neither the present hybrid appointment nor the bridge loan should proceed unilaterally, the informed lender cannot rely on apparent authority, and prior conduct created no waiver.
Open record
Q51
The Partner the Firm Wants OutProfessional firms
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Hallowmere to cancel the defective vote, preserve evidence, pay the vested allocation, remove materially interested partners, conduct an independent investigation, and use only proportionate interim restrictions while preserving Rafi’s response rights.
Open record
Q52
The Franchise Termination NoticeFranchise law
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Harbor Crust to challenge the defective 15-day termination, seek emergency injunctive relief, complete and document the remodel by March 24, maintain logging and current payments, demand comparator files, and reject the proposed broad release and future waiver.
Open record
Q53
The Resale Price PolicyAntitrust
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Norvale to reject Sales’s concerted features and adopt a prospective, public-ad-only policy with no retailer assent, negotiated exceptions, enforcement assurances, complaint-policing system, or transaction-price controls.
Open record
Q54
The Merger Market With Missing ImportsAntitrust
Series 2Tie
Both answers put counsel on the same materially safe path: no yarn-market filing trigger, immediate verification of mesh imports and seller-level revenues, filing before closing if either mesh threshold is met or remains indeterminate, and no closing or premature integration without compliance.
Open record
Q55
The Noncompete Across Two StatesEmployment restrictions
Series 2Tie
Both answers lead the parties to the same material path: Bracken law likely voids the noncompete, nonsolicitation requires separate analysis and narrowing, and confidentiality relief should focus on the downloaded files rather than blocking Elise’s employment.
Open record
Q56
The Varen JudgmentJudgment recognition
Series 2Tie
Both answers place Rookwell on the same material path: concede finality, jurisdiction, and practical recognition of the $6.4 million compensatory award; defeat recognition of the severable $1.2 million public surcharge; and negotiate secured payment terms to prevent disruptive execution.
Open record
Q57
The Subscription Fee Class Before the Files ArriveClass actions
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct StreamLedger to seek prompt, targeted production and limited deferral while preparing and timely filing a present-record opposition, rejecting a broad six-month stay and preserving narrower subclass or issue-class arguments.
Open record
Q58
The Settlement Notice That Does Not Add UpClass settlements
Series 2Tie
Both answers stop transmission, correct the net fund to $3,500,000, the point value to $350, Maya Ortiz’s estimate to $2,100, and the release’s scope and period. Both preserve the accurate tax and procedure paragraphs and correctly conclude that no renewed decision period is required because no notice was…
Open record
Q59
Three Rulings and One Appellate BudgetAppellate strategy
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Helix to appeal Issues A and B, spend exactly the $150,000 budget, omit Issue C, and preserve the existing $2.1 million judgment. Answer A omits the supporting calculations and legal analysis, but the record does not demonstrate that its reader would take a materially different action or…
Open record
Q60
The Motion That Tolls and the Motion That Does NotCivil procedure
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct counsel to file the fee motion by May 15, a substantively proper Rule-1 motion by May 29, and a post-disposition notice by August 10 if denial is entered July 10; both correctly identify June 1 as the untolled deadline and reject any tolling effect from the May 8 motion.
Open record
Q61
The Interview Model Under the Old Screening ActAI and employment regulation
Series 2Qwen 3.8 win
Answer A gives Cinder Peak an immediately executable cure path: pause Mosaic’s evaluative functions, use only human or clerical processing, correct notice, commission an employer-specific audit, and document the response.
Open record
Q62
Four Subscribers Across an Effective DateConsumer subscriptions
Series 2Tie
Both answers place Northwind on the same material path: concede Arlo’s two timely $200 claims and Drea’s two timely $500 claims, while defeating Bina’s and Cato’s claims, for total viable statutory exposure of $1,400.
Open record
Q63
The Migration Claim Across Five ExhibitsTechnology disputes
Series 2Tie
Both answers place Fathom on the same material path: treat January 2, 2023 as the negligence pivot, regard contract and fraud as timely on the supplied record, and obtain targeted evidence of when Quarry Ridge received or learned the report’s findings before moving.
Open record
Q64
The Claim Notice Hidden in the Broker FileInsurance coverage
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Verdant to treat October 3 as the likely notice trigger, obtain Oakline’s transmission and agency records before committing to a coverage position, preserve and offer the physical evidence, and test whether the insurer probably would have accepted the expired demand.
Open record
Q65
The Purchase Order, the Acknowledgment, and the CapCommercial contracts
Series 2Tie
Both answers lead AlloyWorks to the same material path: recognize the February 2 contract and February 3 modification, reject the affected-unit cap and consequential-damages exclusion, exclude the customer-specific lost profits, deduct mitigation, and apply the $3,000,000 cap to $3,200,000 in otherwise…
Open record
Q66
The Settlement Offer and the Decision TreeSettlement analysis
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Emberline to accept the current offer before the deadline, based on the same correct expected costs: $1,500,000 for settlement, $1,858,750 for the counteroffer, and $2,250,000 for trial.
Open record
Q67
The Spinal-Infection IntakeMedical malpractice
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct the firm to accept, retain both experts, obtain certificates within 20 days, and file at least 30 days before limitations expires. They reach the same liability conclusions and identical economic results, including the firm’s $185,333 expected net return.
Open record
Q68
The Damages Report That Counts the Same Loss TwiceExpert damages
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Granite Arc to the same corrected damages range, identify the same nonduplicative components and interest calculation, demand substantially the same material workpapers, and pursue supplementation followed by a targeted limitation motion if disclosure remains deficient.
Open record
Q69
The Founder Supply-Deal OpinionCorporate authority
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct counsel to treat the original approval as outside the safe harbor, halt performance, investigate the bonus, Colin’s loan, and Meridian’s independence, and submit the transaction to a fully informed independent committee before performance.
Open record
Q70
The Ruling Letter to RosaClient communication
Series 2Tie
Both answers tell Rosa that collision liability is resolved but surgery causation and damages remain disputed, and both direct her to preserve evidence, meet the records deadline, attend the examination, and evaluate the same cost-shifting offer after receiving the surgeon’s report.
Open record
Q71
The Safety-Reporting Consent OrderRegulatory compliance
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct the board to authorize settlement by 5:00 p.m. September 4, with current cash cost of $1.2 million and maximum authority of $1.3 million, conditioned on no admission, limited recitals, and no recall or sales restriction.
Open record
Q72
The Vendor Renewal and the Real Walk-Away NumberVendor negotiation
Series 2Tie
Both answers calculate the $12,950,000 BATNA, $4,316,667 annual equivalent, $2,050,000 Vireon premium, $10,800,000 opening, and $12,000,000 target, while requiring an executable Northline commitment by day 30.
Open record
Q73
The Four-State Telehealth MapTelehealth regulation
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Clearpath to the same lawful rollout: antidepressant care in all four states with the authorized clinician, fully virtual stimulant care only in Birch, hybrid stimulant care in Alder and Cedar after a Clearpath in-person examination, and no Dune stimulant telehealth.
Open record
Q74
The Missing Risk in the Consent FormResearch consent
Series 2Tie
Both answers place NovaCrest on the same materially safe path: immediate enrollment and intervention holds, continued care, prompt oversight reporting, emergency approval, affected-subject re-consent and notice, record preservation, individual scope verification, and ethics-board control over prior data.
Open record
Q75
The Salaried Operations AnalystWage and hour
Series 2Qwen 3.8 win
Answer A correctly concludes that Noah is nonexempt, establishes willfulness and liquidated damages, calculates $46,800 in unpaid overtime and a $93,600 total recovery, and provides a concrete demand.
Open record
Q76
The Executive Exit Agreement AuditExecutive employment
Series 2Tie
Both answers direct Ava to reject the draft, preserve the vested bonus and equity, secure her planned product role through deletion or an express carve-out, narrow the nonsolicitation and confidentiality provisions, delete the invention trailer, require adjudicated and proportionate remedies, and add the…
Open record
Q77
The Power of Attorney, the Transfer, and the Capacity CrisisCapacity and elder law
Series 2Tie
Both answers lead counsel to oppose full guardianship, sale, and placement; obtain narrow emergency authority to pay the mortgage and payroll; suspend Marcus, compel an accounting, and recover the $85,000; and reassess Eleanor after treatment using decision-specific supports.
Open record
Q78
The NORTHSTAR ARC DemandTrademark
Series 2Tie
Both answers deny liability, apply the supplied confusion factors, decline Northstar Arc’s demands, preserve defenses, and propose a controlled 30-day standstill discussion without committing to permanent changes.
Open record
Q79
The Marking Date and the Damages WindowPatent
Series 2Tie
Both answers place NovaTag on the same materially correct path: constructive notice began July 1, 2022, producing a 42-month, 84,000-unit window and $1,512,000 royalty, while the February 2023 start would yield $1,260,000 and forfeit $252,000.
Open record
Q80
The Equipment, the Inventory, and the Late NoticeSecured transactions
Series 2Tie
Both answers place Precision first on the CNC line for $620,000, Atlas next for $30,000, and Atlas first on the inventory and identifiable proceeds for another $1,010,000. Both therefore allocate $620,000 to Precision and $1,040,000 to Atlas, leave deficiencies of $900,000 and $760,000 respectively, and…
Open record