# Silverline Mapping — Ordered Protest Plan

**Prepared: Tuesday, September 7, 2027**

---

## 0. Bottom line

The automatic stay is still available, but the window closes **Saturday, September 11, 2027**. Management's plan to file an agency protest on September 10 and wait for an answer **destroys the stay** and lets Atlas begin transition on September 13. The protest must be **received by the Procurement Review Board on or before September 11**, and should in practice be filed **Wednesday, September 8**.

---

## 1. The waived solicitation ground (drop it as a stand-alone ground)

- The five-year polar-region experience requirement appeared **openly on the face of the solicitation** before bids were due. Under Rule 1, an apparent solicitation defect had to be protested **before the bid deadline**.
- Silverline submitted a proposal without protesting. The restrictiveness challenge is **waived**.
- Rule 3 is explicit: the required debriefing delays knowledge of matters *first disclosed there*, but it **does not revive an apparent solicitation defect**. The September 4 debriefing cannot resurrect this ground.
- **Practical instruction:** do not plead "unduly restrictive requirement" as a count. It will be dismissed, and it invites the Board to view the whole filing as untimely-flavored.
- **One preserved variant:** if discovery shows the Authority *relaxed or waived* the five-year requirement for Atlas while enforcing it against Silverline, that is a **disparate-treatment / unequal-standards ground arising post-award**, not a challenge to the solicitation term. Plead it conditionally (see §7) and develop it from the agency report.

---

## 2. Date of knowledge of the post-award grounds

- All three substantive defects — the unidentified sensor model credited to Atlas, the zero credit for Silverline's subcontractor experience, and the tradeoff paying an **$1.8 million premium** — were **first disclosed at the required debriefing on Saturday, September 4**, and confirmed in the written slides the same day.
- **Knowledge date = September 4, 2027.** Under Rule 3 this is the correct trigger; nothing earlier put Silverline on notice of the evaluation mechanics.

---

## 3. Ten-calendar-day Board merits deadline

Rule 2: ten calendar days after knowledge, **excluding the day of knowledge**.

| Count | Date |
|---|---|
| Day 0 (excluded) | Sat., Sept. 4 |
| Day 1 | Sun., Sept. 5 |
| Day 5 | Thu., Sept. 9 |
| **Day 10** | **Tue., Sept. 14** |

**Merits deadline: Tuesday, September 14, 2027.** Weekends count (Rule 9); the Board is open on all relevant dates, so no rollover applies.

⚠️ **September 14 is the deadline to be heard at all — not the deadline to keep performance stopped.** Filing on the 12th, 13th, or 14th yields a live protest with Atlas performing (Rule 5).

---

## 4. The two automatic-stay calculations

Rule 4: stay attaches only if the Board **receives** the protest by the **later** of (a) or (b); triggering day excluded.

**(a) Ten calendar days after award notice (award notice = Wed., Sept. 1)**

| Count | Date |
|---|---|
| Day 0 (excluded) | Wed., Sept. 1 |
| Day 1 | Thu., Sept. 2 |
| **Day 10** | **Sat., Sept. 11** |

**(b) Five calendar days after the required debriefing (debriefing = Sat., Sept. 4)**

| Count | Date |
|---|---|
| Day 0 (excluded) | Sat., Sept. 4 |
| Day 1 | Sun., Sept. 5 |
| **Day 5** | **Thu., Sept. 9** |

**Which controls:** the rule takes the **later** date. September 11 is later than September 9, so **prong (a) — Saturday, September 11, 2027 — controls.**

Note the trap: the debriefing prong here is *shorter*, not longer, because the debriefing occurred only three days after award. Counsel accustomed to assuming the debriefing always extends the stay window would mistakenly calendar September 9 and lose two days of cushion — or, worse, assume some later date and lose the stay entirely.

Also note: September 11 is a **Saturday**, and Rule 9 provides rollover only when the Board is **closed**. The facts state the Board is open on every relevant date, so **there is no rollover to Monday, September 13**. Do not rely on one.

---

## 5. Last filing date that preserves the automatic stay

**Saturday, September 11, 2027 — measured by Board *receipt*, not by dispatch.**

Because the standard is receipt, and because September 11 is a weekend day when electronic docketing, help-desk support, and confirmation of filing may be degraded, treat the operative internal deadline as:

> **File and confirm receipt by Wednesday, September 8, 2027 — three days of margin.**

Obtain and preserve a **written receipt/time-stamp confirmation** from the Board. If the stay is later contested, receipt evidence is the entire fight.

---

## 6. Why the proposed agency-first sequence does **not** protect the stay

The September 10 agency-protest plan fails on four independent grounds:

1. **No stay is triggered.** Rule 6: an agency-level protest "does not trigger the Board's automatic stay."
2. **No tolling.** Rule 6: it does not toll *either* Board deadline — neither the September 11 stay deadline nor the September 14 merits deadline.
3. **The only escape hatch is unavailable.** Tolling occurs only if the agency issues a **written suspension before the Board deadline expires**. The Authority has made **no written commitment** to suspend. An oral assurance, a "we're looking at it," or a contracting officer's informal courtesy is worthless under Rule 6.
4. **The timeline is fatal in fact, not just in theory.** Filing an agency protest on September 10 and "waiting for the agency's answer" means the Board filing occurs after September 11 — stay gone — and almost certainly after **September 13**, when Atlas begins transition work. Agencies do not resolve $28M protests in one day.

**Consequence of the management plan:** Silverline arrives at the Board (if at all before September 14) with Atlas already performing, Silverline bearing the burden of persuading the Board or a court to grant **discretionary** relief (Rule 5), and the entrenchment Silverline itself identifies — transition making "meaningful corrective competition harder" — already underway. Silverline would have voluntarily surrendered the single most valuable procedural asset it owns.

**Revised posture:** an agency protest is not forbidden, but it must be **subordinate and parallel**, never a precondition. See §10.

---

## 7. Grounds to include in the initial Board protest

Rule 8 requires each ground, the supporting facts then known, requested relief, and any request for protected access. Plead all four counts now — Silverline already has the debriefing slides.

**Count I — Evaluation of an unstated sensor model (unequal treatment / evaluation outside the proposal).**
The Authority credited Atlas with a sensor-resolution score based on a model **Atlas did not identify in its proposal**. The score therefore rests on information outside Atlas's submission, cannot be traced to the proposal record, and gave Atlas credit unavailable to offerors evaluated on what they actually wrote.

**Count II — Failure to consider subcontractor experience contrary to the solicitation.**
The solicitation states relevant subcontractor experience "**will be considered**." The Authority assigned Silverline's subcontractor experience **zero** weight. This is a failure to evaluate in accordance with the stated criteria — a mandatory-term violation, not a discretionary judgment. Note this is *not* a solicitation-defect ground: Silverline is enforcing the clause as written, not challenging it.

**Count III — Defective best-value tradeoff.**
The Authority paid an **$1.8 million** premium and justified it solely by the technical scoring attacked in Counts I and II. If either count succeeds, the tradeoff rests on a tainted comparison and cannot stand. Plead independently that the tradeoff rationale is inadequately documented for a premium of that magnitude.

**Count IV (conditional) — Disparate application of the experience requirement.**
Pleaded on information and belief, subject to supplementation: if the Authority relaxed the five-year polar-region requirement for Atlas while enforcing it against Silverline, that unequal application is a post-award ground with a September 4 knowledge date.

**Explicitly excluded:** any challenge to the five-year requirement as unduly restrictive (§1). Consider a one-sentence footnote stating Silverline does **not** advance that waived ground, so the Board does not read Count IV as a disguised solicitation protest.

**Requested relief:** confirmation that the automatic stay has attached; sustain the protest; direct re-evaluation consistent with the stated criteria; terminate or suspend the Atlas award pending re-evaluation; in the alternative, recompete; proposal preparation costs and protest costs.

---

## 8. Protected-record access and supplementation

- **Request protected access in the initial filing.** Rule 8 makes it a pleading element; if omitted, it is not automatically granted. Request the source selection decision document, the technical evaluation worksheets for both offerors, Atlas's proposal volumes bearing on the sensor model, and the tradeoff analysis. Identify cleared counsel and tender any required protective-order undertakings **with the filing** so access is not delayed.
- **Plead facts "then known," not facts hoped for.** The debriefing slides supply concrete, citable facts for all three main counts. Plead them specifically — a stay-preserving filing must still be a legally sufficient pleading; a placeholder protest risks dismissal and forfeits the stay along with it.
- **Reserve supplementation.** Rule 8 permits later supplementation for facts **first learned from the agency report**. State that reservation expressly and re-plead Count IV and any documentation defects once the report arrives. Diary the supplementation deadline the moment the report is received.
- **Sequencing point:** protected access is a reason to file **early**, not late. Filing September 8 rather than September 11 accelerates the agency report and the supplementation window.

---

## 9. Court relief if the stay is lost

Only a fallback. If the September 11 receipt deadline is missed, or the agency obtains an override:

- **Rule 7 factors:** likely success, irreparable harm, balance of harms, public interest. **Rule 7 also warns that filing in court creates no automatic stay** — an injunction motion must be briefed, heard, and granted before September 13 to be worth anything.
- **Likely success:** strongest on Count II. "Will be considered" is mandatory language; zero credit is close to a facial violation.
- **Irreparable harm:** the **$620,000** in proposal costs **cannot** carry this factor — the facts concede proposal costs alone do not establish irreparable harm, and they are compensable in any event. Frame harm instead as the **loss of a fair opportunity to compete**, compounded by transition entrenchment that makes meaningful corrective competition progressively harder after September 13. File before transition, not after, or the harm argument collapses into "too late to fix."
- **Balance / public interest:** a documented evaluation defect on a $28M award favors correction; the government's interest in a lawful, traceable source selection aligns with Silverline. Acknowledge and address transition-disruption costs directly.
- **Parallel option:** Rule 5 also permits the Board to grant **discretionary** relief on a timely-but-late protest. Request Board discretionary suspension simultaneously with any court motion; it is cheaper and faster.

**Weigh the cost:** securing the stay by filing September 8 obtains, automatically and for free, what an injunction motion would cost six figures and might not win. That asymmetry drives the entire sequence.

---

## 10. Exact filing sequence

| # | Action | Date |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Finalize protest: Counts I–III, conditional Count IV, express disclaimer of the waived solicitation ground, relief requested, protected-access request with cleared-counsel designation and protective-order undertakings. Attach the September 4 debriefing slides. | **Tue., Sept. 7** |
| 2 | **File at the Board.** Include a prominent opening paragraph: *"This protest is filed within the automatic-stay period. Award notice issued September 1, 2027; the required debriefing occurred September 4, 2027. Under Rule 4 the controlling deadline is the later of September 11 (award + 10) and September 9 (debriefing + 5) — i.e., September 11, 2027. Performance is automatically stayed."* Obtain a time-stamped receipt. | **Wed., Sept. 8** (hard outer limit: **Sat., Sept. 11**, by receipt) |
| 3 | Serve/notify the contracting officer the same day, in writing, that the Board protest is filed and the stay has attached; request written confirmation that Atlas's September 13 transition is suspended. | **Wed., Sept. 8** |
| 4 | Confirm Board docketing and receipt date in writing. Preserve proof. | **Thu., Sept. 9** |
| 5 | *Optional and only if desired for settlement leverage:* file a parallel agency protest — **after** the Board filing, never before. It neither tolls nor stays (Rule 6); pursue it only if the agency will issue a **written** suspension. Do not let it delay any Board step. | Sept. 9–10 |
| 6 | Monitor September 13. If the Authority permits transition despite the stay, or asserts an override, immediately move the Board to enforce the stay and prepare a Rule 7 injunction motion using the §9 framing. | **Mon., Sept. 13** |
| 7 | Calendar **September 14** as the absolute merits backstop. If anything goes wrong with the September 8 filing, a corrected protest must still be received by September 14 to preserve the merits (Rule 2), even without the stay. | **Tue., Sept. 14** |
| 8 | On receipt of the agency report: obtain protected records, supplement under Rule 8 for newly learned facts, and firm up Count IV. | Post-report |

---

## 11. Key dates at a glance

| Event | Date |
|---|---|
| Award notice | Wed., Sept. 1, 2027 |
| Required debriefing / knowledge of post-award grounds | Sat., Sept. 4, 2027 |
| Stay prong (b): debriefing + 5 | Thu., Sept. 9, 2027 |
| **Stay prong (a): award + 10 — CONTROLS** | **Sat., Sept. 11, 2027** |
| Recommended filing date (3-day margin) | **Wed., Sept. 8, 2027** |
| Atlas transition begins | Mon., Sept. 13, 2027 |
| Board merits deadline (no stay) | Tue., Sept. 14, 2027 |

**Single most important instruction:** do not file an agency protest first. File at the Board by September 8, and in no event later than receipt on September 11.